Open the
Bible Question Form to send your own
question.
Q:
The following is a question I read in "Messianic Perspectives"
(previously called the Christian Jew prior to becoming politically
correct) Newsletter. "The King James Version of the Bible
says that the love of
money is the root of all evil (1Timothy 6:10), but other Bible
versions
say that the love of money is the root of all kinds of evil.
I think the
second translation (non-KJV) is more accurate because money seems
to have
nothing to do with sins like lust or jealousy. What do you think?"
Gary Hedrick (who has since abandoned the KJ Bible after Charles
Halff's passing away) proceeds to answer quoting the Greek text
- "For a root
of all the evils is the money-love". He goes on to list
several Greek words
that use "philos" as a prefix. He points out that Paul
doesn't say it's
"the" root of evil, but rather "a" root;
and, he concludes that "money-love" is but one factor
that brings about evil.
What is your understanding of this passage and please comment
on
the necessity of referring to the Greek text by today's
Bible teachers.
A:
Sometimes, a little research into the Greek or Hebrew can aid in
determining the English definition of the English word that was
chosen by
the translators. However, as a whole (in about 99.8% of the cases),
a
reference to the Greek or Hebrew is made either to correct the
English
(as in your example above) or to exalt the intelligence of the
teacher/preacher. In almost every case, reference to the original
languages does not clarify the meaning but actually muddies the
water of
understanding. Many run to the Greek and Hebrew because they have
not
taken the time to understand the doctrine in question, the message
of the
Bible book, or the English language in context.
However, I do not mean to seem extremely harsh. This is what Bible
students are taught to do from the time they enter Bible College
or
Seminary. They learn it as a habit from teachers they respect.
Therefore,
those who over-emphasize the importance of the original languages
have
much to support them in their approach. People like me who believe
in the
preservation of the King James Bible are those ridiculed as ignorant.
There are some good people who have just not seen the power of
the
English.
The interpretation of 1Timothy 6:10 is an interesting experiment
in these
two approaches to God's word. We are continually told that the
King James
wording is wrong and that the passage can be understood by going
to the
Greek. We are told that the Greek clearly states
"a" root. What people
are usually not told is that the Greek has no equivalent to the
English
"a" or "an." The Greek language has no indefinite
article.
Greek does have a definite article; an equivalent to our "the." The
argument goes that when the "the" is missing, it automatically
means "a"
or "an." Interestingly enough, this is the same argument
used by the
Jehovah Witnesses to "prove" that John 1:1 says
"the Word was a god." Of
course, everyone but the Jehovah's Witnesses know this is foolishness.
The problem is
that interpretation is much more complicated than learning and
applying a
few grammatical rules. We would do better to trust the wisdom
of the King
James translators (who grew up learning the original languages)
and the
providence of God in preserving His infallible word.
So, what can we do with 1Timothy 6:10? What does it mean that "the
love
of money is the root of all evil"? I think we can come to
a conclusion by
making a few observations. First, the root of all evil is not money,
but
the love of money. The root is greed; the desire to have money.
Second,
this love of money is the root of all "evil." We should
note that the
verse does not say that the love of money is the root of every
sin.
Rather, it is the root of all evil. Evil is a more general word
than the
word sin. It refers to the bad things we see in this world. Think
of evil
in its particular manifestations: the evil of drunkenness, the
evil of
prostitution, the evil of war, the evil of pornography, etc. Now
consider
each of these evils. Do they not all find their root in the love
of
money?
True, someone may become drunk for reasons other than the love
of money.
But why is this evil so rampant in the world? Is it not because
greedy
people are trying to make a buck on this evil? The root of every
bar and
dive in every part of the world is the love of money. The same
could be
said of war, prostitution, pornography, and much more. Dig deep
enough
into a societal evil; dig all the way down to the root of why that
evil
is so rampant in the world, and you will find the love of money.
The context of 1Timothy 6:10 adds evidence to this conclusion.
Verse 9
refers to those who because of their desire to be rich, "fall
into
temptation and a snare, and into many foolish and hurtful lusts,
which
drown men in destruction and perdition." Their desire for
money leads
them into other evils; evils like lying, cheating, bribing, and
more.
They are more susceptible to many lustful temptations because of
their
love of money. Follow the chapter back a little more and you find
those
who get into perverse disputings and deny the truth because they
suppose
that "gain is godliness" (1Timothy 6:5). Timothy is warned
to withdraw
from such people. Perhaps they are preachers who change their message
in
order to keep the crowds and their salary. This is an evil and
its root
is the love of money.
Anyway, I have written enough about this topic. It is not as difficult
as
many think it to be. The love of money is still the root of all
evil.